2010 Grant Holt
Striker

2009 Lee Croft
Winger

2008 Dion Dublin
Striker

2007 Darren Huckerby
Forward

2006 Gary Doherty
Defender

2005 Darren Huckerby
Forward

2004 Craig Fleming
Defender

2003 Adam Drury
Defender

2002 Gary Holt
Midfielder

2001 Andy Marshall
Goalkeeper

2000 Iwan Roberts
Striker

1999 Iwan Roberts
Striker

1998 Matt Jackson
Defender

1997 Darren Eadie
Midfielder

1996 Spencer Prior
Defender

1995 Jon Newsome
Defender

1994 Chris Sutton
Striker

1993 Bryan Gunn
Goalkeeper

1992 Robert Fleck
Striker

1991 Ian Culverhouse
Defender

1990 Mark Bowen
Defender

1989 Dale Gordon
Midfielder

1988 Bryan Gunn
Goalkeeper

1987 Kevin Drinkell
Striker

1986 Kevin Drinkell
Striker

1985 Steve Bruce
Defender

1984 Chris Woods
Goalkeeper

1983 Dave Watson
Defender

1982 Greg Downs
Defender

1981 Joe Royle
Striker

1980 Kevin Bond
Defender

1979 Tony Powell
Defender

1978 John Ryan
Winger

1977 Martin Peters
Midfielder

1976 Martin Peters
Midfielder

1975 Colin Suggett
Midfielder

1974 Kevin Keelan
Goalkeeper

1973 Kevin Keelan
Goalkeeper

1972 Dave Stringer
Defender

1971 Ken Foggo
Winger

1970 Duncan Forbes
Defender

1969 Ken Foggo
Winger

1968 Hugh Curran
Striker

1967 Terry Allcock
Defender